Saturday, July 30, 2016

The Scarlet Letter- Hansen

Nathaniel Hawthorne gave a much needed light to women’s rights in the Scarlet Letter, with Hester Prynne's story of one woman’s struggle to find her place, in a time when gender controlled the perceived ability of a woman.  It was unheard of for a woman to speak her mind in the slightest. Hester challenged this way of thinking and way of life within the story, making a vast impression on society. Women were to spend their days taking care of the home and family. To serve as simply an accessory to a man, without much value alone. Times have definitely changed since then, however The Scarlet Letter still has a large relation to the modern day feminist movement. At the beginning of the book, Hester goes along with what everyone tells her what to do. She embroidered a shame filled scarlet “A” onto her clothing, to be reminded of her sinful measures. Then, stood in front of the whole town to be recognized by all as an adulterer and publicly shamed. Women were taught to hide their personalities and to abide by what men taught them. Yet Hester still managed to make a lasting influence.

"Women derive pleasure, incomprehensible to the other sex, from the delicate toil of the needle" (Hawthorne, 76). Hawthorne implies that women cannot let their personal wants show. Because women are to fill their time with housekeeping and embroidery. Ultimately, leading to the idea that women are seen as delicate on the outside, but on the inside have a strong voice that they are struggling to release. “Some attribute had departed from her, the permanence of which had been essential to keep her a woman. Such is frequently the fate, and such the stern development, of the feminine character and person, when the woman has encountered, and lived through, an experience of peculiar severity. If she be all tenderness, she will die. If she survive, the tenderness will either be crushed out of her, or—and the outward semblance is the same—crushed so deeply into her heart that it can never show itself more. The latter is perhaps the truest theory. She who has once been woman, and ceased to be so, might at any moment become a woman again, if there were only the magic touch to effect the transformation.” (Hawthorne, 158). This is a prime example of the stereotypical view of a woman during this time period. A woman will either be too soft to go through something difficult or will lose all tenderness and therefore become less of a woman. As if being tender is the defining feature of a woman and without it you have nothing, because strong women do not exist. Men and women cannot be equal in comparison. As a result, women must have a lesser tenderness, in order to create a more powerful man.

There are clear gender roles throughout the novel. But as it progresses, we see even more evidence of feminist themes. Hester proves that she will not let what society has made her out to be, be who she actually is. The “A” was used originally to label her as an adulterer, however Hester, being the self empowered person she is, would not allow anything to define her, she redefined the letter as a symbol of a strong woman. That is solely what the modern feminist movement is about, becoming distinguished for your own accomplishments instead of what people expect from you based on your gender.

People tend to look up to others that have a stronger will to fight for something they believe in than themselves. Which is why Hester Prynne served as a feminist icon, before it was a movement. Although many women did not act on their beliefs, to please society, it would not be unlikely that Hester was not the only one that felt she was worth more than how everyone treated her. Her and women like her shaped what is widely known today as the fight for gender equality. Through all of her obstacles, Hester served as an early figure of the feminist movement due, to her ability to break her culture's ideal model of a woman and reveal the true capabilities of a woman.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

I agree that women have struggled with expectations today and throughout history such as Hester. There are also many people that fight against these issues.

For women there has always been this image of someone delicate and graceful that is still prominent today. One example of this is in the Olympic Games, specifically gymnastics. Women's gymnastics revolves around grace and beauty, which is the reason why they have music to their floor exercise. While men don't have music to their floor exercise as all their events revolve around strength.

Hester doesn't let the "A" define her, and many of the women in the book shamed her for it. It must have been really hard to keep her head up because walking along the street with everyone shamming you would really hurt my self-esteem. This I think proved that Hester is very strong character and supports her feminist values. I also love her relationship with Pearl. In many of these sorts of stories the women may feel ashamed of their kids that were born from another man other than their mother's husband. Hester never shames her daughter and views her as the most wonderful being in the world, another example of her clear mind and how her opinions differ from others.

Hester is defintely a feminist icon. Even though she's a fictional character her choices and her belief in her self is something many people can admire. There are very few characters portrayed this way, especially in works written in the time period that the book was written in.


Anonymous said...


Hester Prynne is most definitely a feminist icon, and a powerful one too. She doesn’t let her scarlet letter take over her life, and where many women of the time probably would have hidden in shame, she refuses to do so. Hester accepts that the scarlet letter is part of her life and goes through each day brave as ever, staying true to herself and her beliefs despite the criticism she is receiving.

Hester’s experience with being shamed and ridiculed can be a modern-day experience as well; many women and girls, especially in high school, have to deal with a lot of judgement from their peers in general, but drama surrounding relationships seems to get blown even more out of proportion. Judgment over a breakups and relationships are often made into a much larger deal than they really are, especially when it’s really no one’s business but the people involved!

Hester in general is a very strong character, needing not to be rescued by a man and staying strong even through the constant criticism she receives. Hester refuses to reveal the name of the man she committed adultery with and fights back when the mayor attempts to take Pearl from her.

Overall, Hester is a powerful feminist icon and a strong female character who can inspire many women and girls. Hester Prynne is an extraordinary woman, and while it can sometimes be hard to find a book with a strong female lead, Hester is the perfect leading woman.

Anonymous said...

While other books I read this summer definitely had pro-feminism themes, such as The Color Purple, I did not get the impression that women empowerment was one of Hawthorne’s intended overarching themes. While Hester Prynne’s actions can certainly be related to the modern female rights movement, I believe that her struggle with the letter throughout the book had a larger symbolic meaning.
To me, when I read The Scarlet Letter the “A” represented the defining difference between Hester and Arthur Dimmesdale. Hester wore her shame on her shirt so that she could be humiliated by the public while Dimmesdale wore his symbolic “A” in his heart, hidden from the rest of the world. Having committed the same sin, I believe the book focuses on the power of confessions and admitting your sins to God and the world rather than the difference in how men and women are treated for the same crime. While Dimmesdale is physically sick from carrying the burden of his sins, Hester is better off having her sins revealed.
I do, however, agree that Hester can be used as a symbol of woman strength, even if it wasn’t the book’s intention. Being looked down upon by all of society, Hester has the strength to keep her head up and not seclude herself from the world around her. Hester never publicly challenged the gender inequality present in her time, however, her strength and persistence when faced with adversity is strong enough to be used as a symbol not only for women, but also men.