Sophocles and Shakespeare are well known in the dramatic literature world, more commonly Shakespeare, but both are widely appreciated. Hamlet and Oedipus Rex are both tragic stories surrounding the truth and how to deal with it. Hamlet has more emphasis on revenge while Oedipus Rex has more emphasis surrounding prophecy.
In Hamlet the main character, Hamlet, seeks revenge and struggles to find fragments of the truth in order to carry out his revenge. New truths and lies become tangled and ultimately leads to tragedy. Hamlet didn’t immediately latch on to information, he continually looked for more information, while Oedipus in Oedipus Rex latches onto one piece of information and bases everything around that, assuming it was true. This brings up the first difference in the two plays. Truth plays major roles in both the plays, but as said before, the characters handle it differently. Hamlet constantly looks for more of the truth where Oedipus looks for information that only supports one bit of information that may not even be true.
The themes connected to the previous one are different amongst the plays. Hamlet points out the difficulty of creating a plan of action. Hamlet struggles with creating a plan throughout the play as he discovers more and more. His struggles of creating a game plan lead to his death after becoming wounded from Laertes’ poisoned blade. Hamlet’s acceptance of a battle seems reckless and although he succeeds his revenge, his reckless actions lead to his death and the death of many others. In Oedipus Rex the next theme is inevitable prophecies; prophecy is major in Oedipus Rex, and what prophecies to trust, as there are many and many different interpretations of prophecies, is very difficult. Oedipus comes to realize he is the one in the prophecy and the one who killed Laius, so he flees. This decision making the two characters must make is difficult and their decisions bring on their own tragedies.
There are various characters in both the plays and different stories that tie into the main plot of each story, but Oedipus Rex seemed to have much more focus on one plot than Hamlet. In Hamlet there is revenge, but also a bit of a love story. Ophelia was once a girl Hamlet loved and is still in love with. Ophelia is told that her and Hamlet will be together, but is also told to spy on him. This love story gets tangled together with the main plot, served as a distraction in the play that was nice at times but also a bit pointless. But, the love story can also be seen as significant to the tragedy in the story because Ophelia is found dead, bringing despair on many of the characters. Oedipus Rex on the other hand seemed to mostly be focused around a prophecy that would help discover the murderer of Laius. Love is tied into the story as well but it doesn’t become as major as it did in Hamlet. Oedipus and Jocasta are wife and husband and share a bond, this plays into the prophecy well as Jocasta is Oedipus’ mother, fulfilling part of the prophecy. Where in Hamlet the plot for revenge doesn’t rely so much on the love story between Ophelia and Hamlet.
One last theme that are related in the two plays is the sickness of the county/city coming from the sickness within the leaders of that county/city. At the beginning of Oedipus Rex there is discussion about the city and the struggle it is in. The prophecy in the story is believed to solve the issue the city is currently in. In Hamlet the state of the city is so obviously discussed, it is seen more in comparing King Hamlet and Claudius through the eyes of Hamlet. Hamlet sees his father as someone strong, where Claudius is seen as corrupt. Also, the presence of the ghost is seen as indicating something majorly wrong in the world.
These two plays are widely known as tragic stories. The themes are similar in both and connect to the tragedies in both stories along with the tragedies of the people left behind. Both rely on the truth as major aspects and lead to the decisions of major characters.
This weblog is for DeWitt High School's Advanced Placement English Literature class. Students post responses and literary analysis here on themes and techniques used in notable books. This is a team blog and only team members may participate. Check the email address you gave Mr. DeLaCruz for detailed posting instructions.
Tuesday, July 19, 2016
McCarthy and Walker - Fogel
No two authors are ever the same. Every author has their
own unique way of telling the readers their stories, which can be seen when
comparing The Road by Cormac McCarthy
and Alice Walker’s The Color Purple. Yet
there are similarities between the two authors as well. Both Walker and
McCarthy’s styles of writing offer individualistic traits which show their own
styles and personalities of their books, while also containing styles that are
similar to each other.
A big difference between Walker and McCarthy’s
books are their writing styles. The Color Purple consists of a
unique style that is composed of
very short chapters, written as letters to God, which explain the trials and
tribulations that Celie, the main character, experiences. The letters are short
but contain strong feelings and emotions of what she is going through at that
time. Celie’s letters tend to touch upon topics briefly and sparsely rather
than being developed and embellished in long paragraphs. The Road, on the other hand, has a style that is dry and
quite solemn even in the more uplifting moments in the book. This book also
shifts between two different styles. One style is very sophisticated and often
used when he’s talking about something the world has lost in the book. The
other style is quite monotone, which lacks emotion and detailed description of
what is happening. Yet this style has a powerful simplicity that allows the
reader to understand how the characters think differently when faced in certain
situations. The Road is composed of
long and embellished chapters that contain multiple events within each one,
unlike The Color Purple.
Another
noteworthy difference is the how the authors portray the characters. There are
only two main characters in The Road,
which include a man and a boy. Their names are never given, neither their
physical descriptions nor hardly any background information. A few times the Man’s
wife is mentioned when describing a flashback the Man has, but nothing else
about either of their pasts is given. The reader never fully understands why
the Man and the Boy are always on the move and struggling to survive, because
it is never said. The Color Purple,
on the other hand, has multiple characters Walker talks about in the letters. Celie,
the main protagonist, brings up in her letters her abusive dad, her sister
Nettie, her husband Mr. , Shug Avery and more characters throughout
the book. Each one of the characters is described in detail of how they look
and act, which helps as a visual for the reader. This is much different than The Road.
Even
though the Man in The Road is not
described, McCarthy and Walker created very similar main characters despite
their differences. Though Celie is female and the Man is male and both books
are set in different time periods, how both characters act in their difficult
situations are quite the same. In both books, the main characters are going
through very hard times to the point of just trying to survive. But both Celie
and the Man always seem to stand up and protect the people they love, whether
it is Nettie or the Boy. The love the Man has for the Boy and likewise Celie’s
love for her sister Nettie is nearly unbreakable, and they will do anything for
them no matter what the situation. Therefore, both the Man in The Road and Celie in The Color Purple are quite similar when
compared.
Poor grammar
is another shared parallel of The Road
and The Color Purple. Both books
purposefully use bad grammar, but for different reasons. McCarthy's lack
of grammar throughout The Road
can be linked to the content as in the story the Boy and Man are striped of
luxuries in order to survive. The same thing is done with the sentence
structure. The sentences are stripped of their luxuries, in this
case, grammar. This gives the effect of proportion; as the Boy and Man
suffer, the words suffer too. For example, “He pulled the boy closer. Just
remember that the things you put into your head are there forever, he said. You
might want to think about that. You forget some things, dont you? Yes. You
forget what you want to remember and you remember what you want to forget” (12).
McCarthy does away with quotation marks and a lot of punctuation; he rarely
uses apostrophes. As the Boy and Man face hardships, the reader has to face a
minor hardship of trying to figure out who is speaking. In The Color Purple, Walker presents Celie’s thoughts in the
vernacular, with poor grammar and spelling. But instead of using bad grammar to
show the characters’ luxuries being stripped of them as McCarthy did, Walker purposefully
misspells words and uses incorrect grammar in order to emphasize the point that
Celie is not an educated woman. In Celie’s letters, some sentences are so
grammatically incorrect it seems nearly impossible to depict what Walker is
trying to say. For example, “Harpo ast his
daddy why he beat me. Mr._______ say, Cause he my wife. Plus, she stubborn. All women good for—he don’t finish. He just
tuck his chin over the paper like he do. Remind me of Pa” (letter 13).
Both authors use incorrect grammar in their books, but they purposefully do it
for different reasons.
Cormac McCarthy and Alice Walker have won prestigious
awards for their books. They both won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction for The Road and The Color Purple. McCarthy also won the Tähtivaeltaja Award, the Quill Award for General
Fiction, as well as the James Tait Black Memorial Prize for his novel The Road. The Color Purple also received the National Book Award for Fiction.
After comparing and contrasting the authors, writing styles, character
personality traits, purposeful incorrect grammar usage and more, overall
McCarthy’s powerful simplicity within his writing proves to be more meaningful
and masterful.
Sunday, July 17, 2016
Week 4 Explanation
This week’s blog topic asks you to compare and contrast the writing styles of two authors. You can discuss the way the authors structure the book, their choice in point of view, syntax, characterization, pacing, description, theme, symbolism, diction, plot…anything. You may, but don’t have to, say which style you liked better. But DON’T use “I think” or “I believe” or “I” anything -- use third-person point of view. Just state your opinions as fact.
One of the two books you compare should be new to your blog posting. Please write solely in THIRD PERSON and use some quotes (citing them properly).
When you write for this assignment (and most of the others) keep the following general guidelines and possibilities in mind: 1). DO NOT SUMMARIZE. I don’t care if I haven’t read your book; I’m not asking for the plot. 2). Pay attention to your content, ideas, and organization as you structure your post. 3). Certainly mention the book title (use italics to set it off) and author. The title of the post should contain the title of the book and your last name, like in the example that follows these directions 4). Deal with other issues that are interesting, novel, and intellectual yet still relate to the general topic of the post.
Try to have a good time. Remember internet safety protocols: don’t use your entire name or give away identifying information. You should probably change your display name if you’re using your real name. Be tactful and don’t disparage anyone. You are graded on the quality of thought and expression in your post, its length (between 700 - 1000 words), and on using quoted material properly. I suggest writing the post in a word processing program and then pasting it into the post window. Contact me if you have any questions and I’ll answer ASAP. The following example is not a strict template of what you should do but only a possibility, and a poor one at that. Off we go then…
Morrison and Alvarez by de la Cruz
Toni Morrison and Julia Alvarez were both nominated for prestigious writing awards. Morrison was up for the Nobel Prize in Literature and Alvarez was a finalist for the National Book Critics Circle Award; however, only Morrison ultimately received the Nobel Prize in Literature. This distinction in writing accolades serves to illustrate the difference in styles between the two authors. While both Toni Morrison and Julia Alvarez strive to achieve literary excellence, Morrison eclipses Alvarez at leaving a positive impression on the reader. The effect of each author’s technique and the differences between the two are evident in a comparison between Morrison’s Sula and Alvarez’s How the Garcia Girls Lost their Accents.
In Sula and How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents the authors deal with similar subjects. The protagonists in both books are women in a male-dominated society. Each book focuses on the women’s journey from childhood to adulthood and on their connection to one another. The similarities continue in the women’s ethnicities: all the main characters are minorities. In part, the books deal with how these women of color cope within a culture where Caucasians have more power. A greater part of the books, however, asserts the power and tragedy in a being a woman.
On the surface, the plot structure and prose of the books also share many parallels. Time is a key element in Sula and How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents; each book is divided into segments of time. Alvarez divides her book into three time periods and every chapter in Morrison’s tale is named after a year. The prose in each book is also similar in its poetic rhythms and imagery. Morrison, for example, uses the figurative language often used in poetry to describe a day this way: “It had a sheen, a glimmering of green, rain-soaked Saturday nights (lit by the excitement of newly installed streetlights); of lemon-yellow afternoons bright with iced drinks and splashes of daffodils” (94). Alvarez, likewise, uses figures of speech to describe Yolanda’s love interest when she writes, “Let him rip of his white shirt, push back the two halves of his chest like Superman prying open a door and let the first woman out. Eve is lovely, a valentine hairline, white gossamer panties” (69). Both authors also use short sentences and sentence fragments common to poetry.
Whiles these similarities seem significant, it is often the small disparities that make one piece of writing great and another mediocre. Such is the case with Morrison and Alvarez. The first noteworthy difference between the works is the scope. Sula, as the title suggests, is a novel with more focus. There are only two main characters -- Nel and Sula-- the book focuses on. Morrison is conservative in what she chooses to include in the book, so each scene is important to the understanding of the work as a whole. How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents, as the title suggests, has a far broader scope. It not only deals with the four Garcia sisters, but it also includes many side adventures that bog down the conflict and intensity of the work. Soon, the individuality of each girl becomes fuzzy and it is difficult to tell one from the other. Alvarez’s pace meanders, but Morrison’s walks a straighter path.
The second major difference surrounds the characters the authors create and what the characters do. Morrison employs well-defined characters that stick in the reader’s mind: crazy Shadrack with his National Suicide Day parade, feisty Eva missing one leg (after an accident she might have caused herself for the insurance money), and loose Hannah who sleeps with anyone willing. Those are just the supporting characters. The cast in Sula has a spirited life. And death. There is a murder by fire and at least four other fatalities. The Garcia girls, on the other hand, are not as exciting: Carla is a psychologist, Sandra has been institutionalized, Yolanda wants to be a writer, and Sofia eloped with a German. Although Alvarez often changes point of view from third-person to first-person, there is little to give most of the characters a life of his or her own. Furthermore, there is little meaningful conflict: no murders, just a few “off-screen” betrayals, and one threatening -- but absent -- dictator.
Another aspect of why Sula is a more enjoyable piece of literature than How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents is that Alvarez’s style is too melodramatic. When Yolanda, who has also been checked into a psychiatric hospital, asks her shrink what love is “the skin on her neck prickles and reddens. She has developed a random allergy to certain words….her lips swell, her skin itches, her eyes water with allergic reaction tears” (82). Here Yolanda has developed an allergic reaction to the word “love.” Such hackneyed description and characterization crosses a line, stepping out of literature and into common romance novel territory. Morrison’s Sula stays away from sugary notions or reactions to love, death, and many other human sentiments. Her story shows these emotions and situations, but it does not deign to propose that the side effect of a broken heart is as petty as an allergic reaction.
For these reasons and more, Toni Morrison was able to add the Nobel Prize in Literature to her Pulitzer and her National Book Critics Circle Award. Though both Morrison and Alvarez tackled shared topics, themes, and genders, after comparing Sula to How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents, Morrison’s literary style has proven to be more masterful.
Saturday, July 16, 2016
The Color Purple - Jess Ruby
Letters to God
Hiding behind hope
The only way to cope
Violence is not the key
Careful not to go as low as he
Internal struggle for hate or love
To write is to help you rise above
You have been used
Your mind and heart abused
The pain you endure
Not only your body does he injure
Your mind is just as strong
Trusting god to right his wrong
Answer your prayers, God will
Your faith he can’t kill
Keep writing
Keep fighting
This way of life will soon end
Your wounds God will mend
This poem describes my feelings towards Celie’s writing. They serve as an outlet for her frustrations, and allow her to remain hopeful and rely on her faith in God. I think that even today writing serves as a powerful tool to many in terms of coping. Even with what she has been through, Celie remains hopeful and has continued to write to God. I think that this is a very important part of the story and makes it that much more powerful seeing things from her perspective.
Expectations
Expectations
the words keep replaying
what message are they relaying
not sure of their importance
I guess I’ll just ignore it
that's what I end up doing
how do I keep moving
when I know I’ll never meet them
only existing to condemn
Expectations
Future coming soon
sounds like a horror film
that doesn’t interest me
one I don’t care to see
It has bad reviews
it’s time to spread the news
Why spend my time and money
if I know I’ll end up unhappy
just trying to achieve
these goals set by
Who?
Expectations
That is the question though
how do you even know
what I’m supposed to be
when it's a mystery to me
put the answers on a pedestal
perfection seems critical
but why
who are we following?
Expectations
Maybe we knew at some point
sorry to disappoint
but I forgot
put me on the spot
and I will tell you
that these goals you set for me
who ever you may be
I don’t care
just putting it out there
I’d rather make my own
Step down from your throne
I have a chance to thrive
but on my own time
My Expectations
This poem relates to the struggle in Harpo‘s head about his father’s expectations. He doesn’t truly want to be like his Father, but somewhere deep down he doesn’t want to disappoint him. His feelings incompetence are only confirmed once again by the disapproval he faces from Sophia’s father, and the fact that his strength is inferior to that of his wife’s. She challenges him and out of fear of losing his manhood and respect from other men he slips into the disgusting ways of self proclaimed dominance like the other men in his life. He struggles internally with his own values that become clouded by those of others.
Like a Man
I must display my dominance today
I fancy the girls that come out at night
The one I married will just have to pay
My incompetence comes out when I fight
I have to hit my wife because I can
My mind has been taken over with greed
Her bruises make me feel more like a man
It’s not her pain but the power I need
Went out at night and thought i was clever
I love Shug though she doesn’t love me
Celie knows but leave me she would never
I brought her to my home so she could see
That I am the man with whom she belongs
Voice in my head like my favorite song
I wrote this sonnet poem from the perspective of Mr. ____ about his feelings towards Shug Avery. He is so blown away by her beauty that he can’t get her out of his head, and brings her into his home when she comes ill. The fact that she doesn’t respect him, even in his own home and he still cares for her shows how strong his attraction to her is. He takes out his anger on his wife Celie, because it helps him feel more powerful when Shug takes that away from him. This is a good representation of the treatment of women in this time period which is an important part of the setting in this book.
The Kite Runner, Wescott
Lifeless Trophy
The shapes above with speed they dart so fast
The sea of color in the sky no more
A single kite is triumphant at last
I’m filled with pride, the blast of chants they roar
The chase for the trophy ensues with speed
The best day in my life is almost real
Turn the corner to find a friend in need
I run away despite the choice I feel
I hear the screams inside my head each day
Regret putting myself before my kin
Now with a prize that is so great they say
But lost a part of me, my pride within
On the outside it is a win with glee
Inside I feel alone, helpless, not me
This Sonnet tells the event that occurred during Amir’s win at the kite fighting tournament in The Kite Runner. The first quatrain is uplifting as Amir’s become victorious over the other kites. The second quatrain transitions from one of his greatest moments in his life into the one he most regrets, not saving Hassan in the alley. This was a major event in the book and changed Amir’s character drastically. Amir can never let it go as mentioned in the first line of the third quatrain. Even though all of his friends and family are so proud of him, all Amir feels is regret for his actions that day.
Looking
Into the city I am looking for something
Will I find it?
I’m looking for a boy
I want to go back
But I have to find it
So I can finally sleep a night
The daunting memories of the past
Lead me here
I am frightened
A sudden pain fills me
Along with the peace I desired
I can finally sleep once again
This free verse poem is describing Amir (in his point of view) searching for Hassan’s son in Kabul. I wanted to make the poem very abstract and not follow any rhythm because this was a moment in the book where Amir believed he was looking for the boy, when in reality he was looking for a way to make up his mistake that has troubled him all his life (this is how I perceived it). The poem say “will I find it”, making it seem like “the boy” at first but it end up being at peace with himself. The pain (Asself beating him) allows Amir to receive the punishment for leaving Hassan in the alley, which causes him to finally be free from the resentment and recollection of the event.
Baba
I have looked up to you since I was little
You are so strong while I am so brittle
You are outgoing and help those in need
While am quiet and turn when they plead
I know you are disappointed in me
How mom died giving birth to your first baby
But please give me a chance, my love for you is vast
With the win I got your love, but that didn’t last
I get jealous when you put Hassan over me
I’m not as weak as you think, wait one day you’ll see
Our world is changing, we can start a new life
Where we can agree instead of having a strife
We are in a new place and can finally say
We understand one another today
And when I finally lay you to rest one night
I can remember how we made everything right
This final poem is another free verse that has rhyming and a structure. It shows the relationship between Amir and his father (who he called Baba). Their relationship started out with Baba being disappointed in Amir, in part for all their differences and because Amir killed his wife while giving birth to him. This causes Baba to give more attention to Hassan, who has a character similar to Baba’s. However, once the two move to America, they are able to settle their differences and finally create a healthy relationship between them. This moment in the book meant a lot to me as I could sympathize with Amir. Even if a relationship has hardships, they can be resolved as long as there is love.
The Handmaid's Tale - Dell
Red (Freeform Prose)
Color of anger,
Failure of the womb.
Color of passion,
Feverish lust.
Color of prison,
My fabric cage.
Anger will burst,
The womb won’t be needed.
Passion will soar,
Our love is freedom.
Prison will fall,
Tear the cotton to the floor.
For the oppressor is obsolete.
Red was one of my favorites to write because
it actually has a happy ending. This describes the fall of Gilead after years
of suffering under its oppressive rule. I chose the color red as the topic
because not only does it describe the dresses of the handmaids, but it also can
describe a range of emotions and feelings, such as rage, lust, and power. The
first stanza tells of the years of control that Gilead had over the handmaids
and other women, but the second stanza tells that this isn’t true anymore, because
the resistance has won over the republic.
Mother (Free verse with rhyme)
Her shouts of pain hit deaf ears,
Their suffering all became one.
My bearer’s single purpose,
Was all but good and done.
They took me to the witch’s arms,
From God she took a drink.
And shut out my dear mother’s face,
So I might never think.
They sent her to another wife,
To bless me with a sister.
But God said stop this ticking clock,
And they let her poor hands blister.
This poem represents
a birthday in the book The Handmaid’s
Tale. The first stanza references the handmaid’s who were present during a
birth (specifically Janine’s), claiming that they could feel phantom pains in
their own stomachs and back. However, no one important is concerned with the
women’s pains or feelings, they only pay attention to the wife and “her” soon
to be daughter. As soon as the baby would be born, the biological mother’s
purpose in the home would be over. The second stanza describes how the baby
would be taken to the arms of the wife, often considered to be hard, unfeeling
women (probably especially in the eyes of the mother and daughter), which is
why I referred to her as a witch. The drink from got references how handmaids
were referred as “chalices filled with wine”, the pregnant ones, that is. The
wife is considered to be “taking a drink” from this chalice, and the child is a
gift from the Lord. The last two lines describe how the literal mother would be
sent away from the child so that they may never know their real bearer. Lastly,
the final stanza once again references the mother being sent away so she could
birth another offspring from another commander. However, her “biological clock”
runs out and she is no longer fertile, so she is sent to the colonies to be
worked to death, as referenced by the “blistering hands” from physical labor.
Women (Italian Sonnet)
How may I serve my God from my being?
My mind holds treasures found in page and
pen.
Lips bear gold from spindles birthed by
wise men.
Both my eyes can view what they are seeing.
Heard of woman teaching word from
reading?
These hands have worked to wrangle feathered
hen.
So clearly there is work that I may tend,
Because our society needs feeding.
But I am told to be a girl of Eve,
For God has blessed my chalice to bear
wine.
So they tell me my brothers only read.
Power cannot be held in our naive,
We only get value for months of nine.
The Earth is for us women to plant seed.
Women describes
how a religious girl might feel excited to serve the established republic of
Gilead, asking what work she may do to assist. She goes through and lists her
qualities that make her just as capable to do work as a man, such as reading,
education, social skills, world views, and also skills in cooking and teaching.
However, the sestet tells her the republic of Gilead only has one purpose for
her: reproduction. She is not viewed as the body of knowledge and potential
that she is, and is forced to “work” under the government’s oppressive hand.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)