Saturday, July 23, 2016

Nathaniel Hawthorne and Khaled Hosseini by Nordmann

While Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter and Khaled Hosseini’s The Kite Runner span a gap of over 150 years, they surprisingly have more in common than one would think. The severe differences between the two authors and their novels may be what is first noticeable, but upon further inspection the similarities between the two become evident. Although Hawthorne crafts a tale set around a middle aged women living in Massachusetts during the mid seventeenth century and Hosseini writes about the life of a young Afghani boy during the late twentieth century, both of these novels address the themes of love and guilt, connecting these two seemingly unlike authors. Even with these similarities, Hawthorne and Hosseini are able to showcase how audiences and writing style have developed over the years through their contrasting syntax, diction, and pace.

Themes of love can be found in books spanning all cultures, continents, and centuries, so having these two authors address that in their novels isn’t that astonishing. It’s the way they both craft a complicated relationship between a parent and their illegitimate child, how they cope with the repercussions of their acts, and how they attempt to love them in their own way but ultimately cannot escape the guilt. On one hand with Arthur Dimmesdale and Pearl, Hawthorne allows readers to know that Arthur is Pearl’s father before the majority of the other characters in his book, which allows us to see how his denial of the affair effectively causes his demise. He tries to find his redemption from God, but in the end he allows his guilt to internalize and eat him alive, leaving nothing but an empty shell. On the other hand with Baba and Hassan, Hosseini adds an interesting element by omitting the true nature of their relationship until the end of the book, so the reader is kept in the dark along with Amir and Hassan. Baba never gets the chance to tell Amir or Hassan the truth before he passes, and Hassan never gets the opportunity to learn of his true father. Upon reflection, it is obvious to both the reader and Amir what a toll this takes on Baba. Much like Arthur Dimmesdale, he is ridden with guilt. He, however, chooses to deal with his guilt in a different way. Baba chooses to try and find redemption in worldly things, “… feeding the poor on the streets, building the orphanage, giving money to friends in need, it was all his way of redeeming himself” (Hosseini 302). Hawthorne and Hosseini both demonstrate the need for love and the guilt that comes from trying to seek redemption. 

Although there are many similarities in the themes Hosseini and Hawthorne choose to address, the passage of time between their novels becomes unmistakable when examining their prose. Hawthorne writes in a much older form of English, using words that are rarely used in our modern times. In addition, Hawthorne’s syntax varies greatly from Hosseini’s, but this could be contributed, in part, to their audience. Today’s general public expects information to be direct and to the point, with little patience for details not relevant to the main storyline. This results in The Kite Runner being written in a more blunt and forthright tone while The Scarlet Letter tends to have lengthy paragraphs describing characters, settings, and other facets of the plot that today’s readers would deem “unnecessary”. The style in which Hawthorne writes causes readers to contemplate and be challenged by his ingenuity. For example, in the conclusion of The Scarlet Letter, Hawthorne makes a compelling observation about the nature of love and hate, “Philosophically considered, therefore, the two passions seem essentially the same, except that one happens to be seen in a celestial radiance, and the other in a dusky and lurid glow” (Hawthorne 312). Hosseini on the other hand overuses literary devices such as metaphors and smilies; but does somewhat acknowledge his tendency to do so, “ …but I always thought clichés got a bum rap. Because, often, they're dead-on. But the aptness of the clichéd saying is overshadowed by the nature of the saying as a cliché” (Hosseini 197). The point he makes is fairly valid but it makes for a tiresome read when used too frequently. 

Pace is another large factor that has changed throughout the years and is contrasted in these two novelists. In today’s fast paced society, readers expect to be constantly stimulated, with little downtime in between major events. Hosseini certainly delivers on this front, filling his book with many layers and circumstances for Amir to preserve through. The downfall to this is that if it is not well written, it can almost become repetitive. The Kite Runner is filled with poetic justice, especially at the end, which becomes too picture perfect to be realistic, ruining the illusion of Amir’s world for the reader. The Scarlet Letter, on the other hand, is much slower paced, but the action that does come causes the reader to hang on to every word. Granted the occasional passage can get a little tedious, but the climaxes and turning points of the novel make up for it by causing readers to savor the action and appreciate the shocking twists Hawthorne provides. 

Overall, Hosseini and Hawthorne demonstrate how literature has been able to stay constant throughout the years while still evolving with the culture around it to stay relevant to new generations of readers. 



Hawthorne and Walker - Koski

Nathaniel Hawthorne and Alice Walker are among some of the most influential authors of classic American literature. Each author is characterized by unique aspects included in their pieces that entice audiences to continue to read their novels, even today. Although the authors were alive in vastly different time periods and they wrote with dissimilar styles, they were both able to address serious topics in a historical context. They confronted similar issues and their novels The Scarlet Letter and The Color Purple comparatively show both Hawthorne and Walker’s writing capabilities. 

Hawthorne’s pieces worked to give character to America during a time when America was trying desperately to define itself. His early pieces earned him the title, “The American Shakespeare”, and many people identify him today as a literary great. He had many prestigious acquaintances willing to vouch for his work; including Franklin Pierce, Herman Melville, Ralph Waldo Emerson, and Margaret Fuller. Emerson and Fuller later pushed Hawthorne into transcendentalism, and many of his novels portray transcendentalist ideals. For example, The Scarlet Letter makes a clear distinction between good and evil. The Dark Man, many people believe is the devil, and Chillingworth seems to embody evil with his plots of revenge. The continuing themes of transcendentalism, Puritan societies, and religion are relevant in many of Hawthorne’s pieces. In The Scarlet Letter, Hawthorne examines the link between sexism and the way the Puritans punish Hester. He explains their failing use of symbols to portray their ideology: such as the scarlet letter A, over time it loses meaning and Hester sees the scarlet A as a defining characteristic, and not as a part of a punishment. Thus she is strong and insightful. Alice Walker may not have been defined as an “American Shakespeare”, however she fearlessly addresses the controversial issues of an earlier time period. Walker’s work was inspired by her life as a civil rights activist. She was willing to confront the issue of racism and lack of women’s rights in her novel The Color Purple. Walker would go on to win a Pulitzer Prize for her bravery. 

Hawthorne and Walker are willing to address similar ideals such as the mistreatment of women. Hawthorne exemplifies this with his use of the Puritan society Hester Prynne is residing in. She faces ridicule and exile from those living in her community for committing adultery. However, Hester is strong. She takes the punishment in stride and her exile allows her to be free thinking and observant about her community. Walker starts her novel off with a disturbing scene of the main character, Celie, being sexually abused by her father. Over time, Celie learns more about her experiences with abuse from the women she surrounds herself with. In her talks with Sofia, she learns that she can be strong in the face of her abusers. She realizes for the first time in her life that she can stand up for herself and fight the mistreatment she has been receiving. Furthermore, each author features religion frequently. The Scarlet Letter thoroughly utilizes the Puritan Society and their inability to separate church and state. The Puritans turned to their religion to solve their problems and saw life as the event separating you from Heaven. For example, Dimmesdale punished himself for his sins, trying desperately to repent and reach out to God to cope with his guilt. Although Walker does not write about religion in the same extreme, it becomes increasingly evident throughout the novel that Celie is dependent on God to help her get through her troubles. “I have to talk to Old Maker… This life soon be over, I say. Heaven last all ways” (Walker). 

However, the similar themes are where the similarities between Hawthorne and Walker end. Hawthorne writes with a sophisticated tone. He uses scholarly diction clearly from his time period. His long sentences in Olde English thoroughly convey his thoughts and give life to the many characters. He defines Hester by her experiences rather than flat out giving her a back ground. Walker however writes with misspellings, atrocious grammar, and no quotation marks. She does this intentionally to convey how uneducated Celie really is. Furthermore, every passage is a letter addressed to God. Hawthorne employs the third person point of view which allows his story to include the viewpoints of several characters. Advantageous to readers because they are introduced to several people who help to move the story forward, but also consequential because the audience lacks the ability to form a personal connection with any one character. Walker employs a first person point of view. Every letter is in Celie’s perspective. Advantageous to readers because they are able to develop a close bond with Celie, however consequential because other characters are never introduced in depth. 

In summary, each author has the courage to address controversial topics. Each define their characters by the events happening to them and each author includes a strong female perspective in their most famous works (The Scarlet Letter and The Color Purple). Additionally, each author defines historical points in American history. Both authors characterize the categories their pieces belong to. Hawthorne defines America, gives voice to the early beginnings of the country, and eloquently showcases the actions of our ancestors. Walker describes horrific realities for blacks and women, exemplifies the psychological effects of violence and abuse, and provides the backbone to a movement lead by female authors. Each author is great in their own unique aspect, and they will continue to symbolize American literature at its finest. 

Hossieni and McCarthy


These two authors, Cormac McCarthy and Khaled Hosseini share many differences, but have the same mission and that is to leave the reader breathless and thinking about what they just read for many days after. McCarthy and Hosseini both write about struggle in their books The Road and The Kite Runner in two styles that come across as very polarizing, but when analyzing the main message of these two books, their styles are like peanut butter and jelly- they have very different tastes but when put together they mesh perfectly.
 McCarthy’s signature is shown all throughout his writing which is his unique grammar and symbolism that separates him from many other modern day authors. In a way his style is similar to poetry; the structure of his sentences have its own meaning just like the words do. This style makes the reader hone in just not to the words McCarthy uses, but the way he uses them and why. It’s hard not to wonder why this type of style used in his book, The Road but at the same time The Road couldn’t have been written in any other way. The Road’s lack of grammar has a strong message showing that a book doesn’t particularly need things like quotation marks in order to be understood or well liked. Instead, McCarthy focuses on what he thinks makes a book well written which is the usage of powerful sayings and images that will make the reader stumped and dumbfounded. For example, McCarthy uses vivid imagery: “How would you know if you were the last man on Earth? He said. I don’t guess you would know it. You’d just be it. It wouldn’t make any difference. When you die it’s the same as if everybody else died too.” The Road (168). This saying just like several other notable sayings from The Road really makes one think. The bluntness to McCarthy’s writing is like a slap in the face. The political incorrectness of quotes like on page 168 melding with the lack of structure is exactly like reading a long, brutal poem. The Road symbolizes all of the corruption in the world through character like the roadagents and how survival of the fittest is in every aspect of life, not just through man vs. man, but in man vs. himself.
The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini had the same aspect of man vs. man and man vs. himself just like The Road did. Throughout The Kite Runner, the reader was introduced to how much corruption there was in Afghanistan and how that filtered its why into the mind of its civilians. Although The Kite Runner didn’t use lack of grammar and structure like The Road did, there were some similarities in style of McCarthy and Hosseini through sentence structure to make Hosseini’s point even more visible. For example on pages 294 and 295 Hosseini uses repetition to leave the reader with a mood tinged with seriousness. The phrase “I fade out” used five times had the same power that McCarthy did with his imagery. The Kite Runner had its own way of showing the struggle of survival through real life situations that people like Amir had to go through. Amir struggled with shame and physical injuries throughout the book just like the man struggled with the abyss unknown in the apocalyptic world as well as physical injuries. Although Cormac McCarthy and Khaled Hosseini wrote two books about totally different situations, they share the same sense of style when it comes to showing struggle. McCarthy didn’t have chapters and structure to separate thought like Hosseini did, but that didn’t stop the imagery and symbolism pour into their writing. 

Atwood and Dickens- Hegerfeld

All authors have their own ways of writing literary pieces. From the ways they unfold a plot to detailing a character's profile, every aspect of an author's literary styles differ from another. This is very evident when comparing the books, The Handmaid’s Tale, by Margaret Atwood, and A Tale of Two Cities, by Charles Dickens. These two Authors have major differences in the ways they write as well as similarities, mostly because of the very different time periods of the books, as A Tale of Two Cities was published in 1859, compared to 1985 when The Handmaid’s Tale was published.
The first and possibly most obvious difference is the genres the two authors use. Charles Dickens wrote A Tale of Two Cities in a historical drama way where Margaret Atwood used a science fiction approach. Now, neither of these two styles are completely non-fiction, which is a similarity, but Dickens’ book is written off true events compared to Atwood, who wrote in the future. The events in A Tale of Two Cities may not have actually happened, but both London and Paris went through revolutions where the top monarchs were overthrown by lower class citizens, and people were put in jail on completely false accusations. The Handmaid's Tale, while not impossible, but the the events that took place in this book probably will not happen, at least in the near future.
The two authors also have quite different writing styles. Because Dickens wrote his book more than one hundred years before Atwood did, he has what seems like much more lofty diction. Although this was just the norm back in the 1800’s, compared to now words like besmirch (smear as to make dirty or stained) and bacchanalian (used of riotously drunken merrymaking) look very intelligent. Another difference in writing style that the two books do have, is the point of view that they are written in. A Handmaid’s Tale is written in the first person point of view by the character Offred. Just about all of the book is her telling us (the reader) her story and her past life. On the contrary, A Tale of Two Cities has a narrator who is never identified, that knows all the characters and tells their stories.
A small but notable similarity of the two authors in these pieces were the book’s structure.  Although not exactly alike, both books were made up of full, exciting chapters that were never too short and left out information. This also applies to the sentences. Similar to the paragraphs,  both Atwood and Dickens wrote with eventful, and lively sentences to make the books flow and keep the audience in tune.
Finally, the last big difference that is very noticeable was the way the two authors used characters. In A Tale of Two CIties, all the characters were introduced and briefly described, but not very many of them got full descriptions, leaving the reader the opportunity to imagine how the characters look to themselves. Also, Dickens jumps around a few times, focusing between the two topics of the french and english revolution. Although it all intertwines, his style creates a sort of confusing book because the reader must pay attention to events happening on both parts to understand the book well. When looking at The Handmaid’s Tale, the main character, Offred, is described in full, leaving little room to think up a colorful image of her. The rest of the characters aren't as described as her, but they are all given a thoughtful explanation. But, for the entire book Offred is the one telling the story, minimizing confusion. Within these differences, there are small similarities, too. In both writings, characters make special bonds with other characters that are evident throughout the entirety. It is clear in both who the main characters are and who they like and dislike.
The way Margaret Atwood wrote is an easier to understand type of style. The more modern language provided better comprehension of her book, which results in a better read. Also, since the Handmaid’s Tale was written in a first person perspective, rather than a third person view, it allowed us as the reader to create stronger bonds with characters because we got to really see how the main character got to interact with others.

Cormac McCarthy and Khaled Hosseini Week 4 Madison Deiter


These two authors, Cormac McCarthy and Khaled Hosseini share many differences, but have the same mission and that is to leave the reader breathless and thinking about what they just read for many days after. McCarthy and Hosseini both write about struggle in their books The Road and The Kite Runner in two styles that come across as very polarizing, but when analyzing the main message of these two books, their styles are like peanut butter and jelly- they have very different tastes but when put together they mesh perfectly.
 McCarthy’s signature is shown all throughout his writing which is his unique grammar and symbolism that separates him from many other modern day authors. In a way his style is similar to poetry; the structure of his sentences have its own meaning just like the words do. This style makes the reader hone in just not to the words McCarthy uses, but the way he uses them and why. It’s hard not to wonder why this type of style used in his book, The Road but at the same time The Road couldn’t have been written in any other way. The Road’s lack of grammar has a strong message showing that a book doesn’t particularly need things like quotation marks in order to be understood or well liked. Instead, McCarthy focuses on what he thinks makes a book well written which is the usage of powerful sayings and images that will make the reader stumped and dumbfounded. For example, McCarthy uses vivid imagery: “How would you know if you were the last man on Earth? He said. I don’t guess you would know it. You’d just be it. It wouldn’t make any difference. When you die it’s the same as if everybody else died too.” The Road (168). This saying just like several other notable sayings from The Road really makes one think. The bluntness to McCarthy’s writing is like a slap in the face. The political incorrectness of quotes like on page 168 melding with the lack of structure is exactly like reading a long, brutal poem. The Road symbolizes all of the corruption in the world through character like the roadagents and how survival of the fittest is in every aspect of life, not just through man vs. man, but in man vs. himself.

The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini had the same aspect of man vs. man and man vs. himself just like The Road did. Throughout The Kite Runner, the reader was introduced to how much corruption there was in Afghanistan and how that filtered its why into the mind of its civilians. Although The Kite Runner didn’t use lack of grammar and structure like The Road did, there were some similarities in style of McCarthy and Hosseini through sentence structure to make Hosseini’s point even more visible. For example on pages 294 and 295 Hosseini uses repetition to leave the reader with a mood tinged with seriousness. The phrase “I fade out” used five times had the same power that McCarthy did with his imagery. The Kite Runner had its own way of showing the struggle of survival through real life situations that people like Amir had to go through. Amir struggled with shame and physical injuries throughout the book just like the man struggled with the abyss unknown in the apocalyptic world as well as physical injuries. Although Cormac McCarthy and Khaled Hosseini wrote two books about totally different situations, they share the same sense of style when it comes to showing struggle. McCarthy didn’t have chapters and structure to separate thought like Hosseini did, but that didn’t stop the imagery and symbolism pour into their writing. 

Sophocles and Miller - Smith

What is the difference in writing that makes one author/ playwright widely known and famous for hundreds of years, and one that just fades into obscurity? This is the difference between Sophocles, the great Greek playwright, and Arthur Miller who had some hits but never received much recognition for his plays. Sophocles was an ancient Greek tragedian who wrote over 120 plays. He participated in 30 competitions winning 18 and never placing lower than second. Miller came from a middle class family and had over 30 plays. He was nominated for an Oscar for The Crucible, but never won any awards for his work, some might say he is more known for being married to Marilyn Monroe than anything else. That is not very true, but it goes to show he never made it big. The differences between the two men’s writing can be seen in the plot, themes and characterization from Death of a Salesman and Oedipus Rex.

The general plot between the two plays is very similar. They both start with a male protagonist who is confused/ crazy. Both characters have a problem but keep telling themselves lies or just disregarding the truth so they don’t have to be the bad guy. In the end they both discover the truth which sends them over the edge and causes them to cause physical harm and therefore removing themselves from the situation. The general plot is similar, but it is the little differences that make Sophocles work live on. For example Sophocles uses dramatic irony from the beginning when the blind prophet says that it was Oedipus that killed King Laius “from this day address neither these men here nor me, since you are the unholy polluter of this land” (22). This allows the audience to see Oedipus slowly learn what they know and watch as he slowly accepts the truth. It leaves them in suspense when Oedipus learns what they already know because they don’t know what his reaction is when he goes postal. On the other hand Willy is already losing his mind from the beginning of the play. This takes away a lot of the character development that would allow the audience to really be drawn in and connect with his problems. Emotion also something that will make a play boom or bust, and especially at the end where both men realize the truth. Miller uses a short, vague ending that has very little emotion in it. Miller doesn’t even tell you that Willy dies but only uses stage directions “There is the sound of a car starting and moving away at full speed... as the car speed off the music crashes down in a frenzy... All stare down at the grave” (136). This ending is very undramatic, and rather boring considering that Willy tried to commit suicide before. It is just short and leaves people a little sad. Sophocles on the other hand uses a very long, descriptive, and emotional reaction. It doesn’t leave the audience what happened to Oedipus because it makes sure to show you in great detail. Once he learns the truth he goes into a fit of rage ready to kill his mother/wife when he see’s she killed herself he becomes very somber and then claws his eyes out with her brooches and asked to be exiled from the kingdom. It is emotionally charged and draws the audience/ readers in and then leaves them stunned at Oedipus reactions. This outburst of emotion is a very good conclusion to the story especially as the audience could watch the tension build and build.

Another important factor to the life span of a literary work is the lessons that can be learned from them. In Death of a Salesman, Miller theme was focused on the American Dream and how it's not how good you look and how much your liked, but instead how hard you work. This is a great lesson as there are numerous other works that has the same theme. The only thing is that it allows for a small group of people to really relate to it. Not all Americans will be able to connect to it as they are already happy with what they are doing, or are already well off. Internationally it won’t be a big hit because the American dream is most relatable for people living in the US or the immigrants that move there. Sophocles however uses a central theme that is universal and will always apply to any society and that is the rejecting the truth and the consequences that come with it. As the play progressed Oedipus was continually told and given more evidence that it was he who killed king Laius bringing the plague on the kingdom, and he kept denying it. It was because he kept denying it that made it worse and lead him to discover other facts that lead to the suicide of his mother/wife and him to claw out his eyes. Sophocles is so successful in part because his play’s apply to all people regardless of time and location where Miller’s themes are more specific to certain people in a specific place and time.

Lastly, as touched on before Sophocles developed his characters a lot more. As the play advanced you saw their complexity and got to know a little about how they thought which then allayed you to predict how they would react to a truth. While Miller had the characters already developed where Willy was already losing his mind and the resentment from Biff was from before the play started.This causes the audience to be less attached to the play. In conclusion Sophocles work as lasted for hundreds of year because he uses universal themes, more emotion and description and develops his characters more than Arthur Miller does. Miller by no means is a bad playwright, only his plays are not on the same level as the great playwright that Sophocles was.

Miller and Shakespeare - Ozbun

Arthur Miller and William Shakespeare created two of the most widely known plays in history. One being written more than three hundred years before the other. Yet both plays are still widely known and often recreated to be shown to today’s audiences. These authors are quite similar in the themes and concepts they give off in both pieces that have thus transcended through many years of literature, However in Miller’s Death of a Salesman and Shakespeare’s Hamlet, there are plenty of differences in tone, pacing, diction, and writing style. Even being written years apart as they were, they did seem to share similarities in the plot nevertheless.
First the authors have a shared focus on plot and concepts in both pieces of literature. In both plays, concepts such as sanity and reality play a huge role in the plots. Hamlet is continually haunted by the ghost of his father throughout the play. It is even to the point at which he sees things while in the presences of other people. Quite frequently Hamlet’s sanity is questioned and if he is in the right state of mind. Both father and son, WIlly and Biff in Death of a Salesman are also frequently haunted by memories of the past. The hauntings that occur to Hamlet are much more explicit than the hauntings that occur to WIlly and Biff. As in example, in Act I, Scene 5, Hamlet has a full conversation with the ghost of his father. Most of the hauntings in Death of a Salesman revolve around Willy’s disloyalty in his marriage. The concept of reality is even brought forth in both plays, from Hamlet’s visions of his father to Willy’s faded past. Not only a similarity in concept, but there is a large similarity in plot as well. There is a large similarity in the relationships in both plays. The relationship between father and son is huge and instrumental to both of the plays glory and fame. Throughout the whole play of Hamlet, the protagonist strives to avenge his father’s murder. Hamlet keeps thinking about his revenge on his murderous uncle and the murder is pivotal to the stories plot. In Death of a Salesman, the story is based on the life of a salesman father Willy. WIlly desperately wants his son Biff to make it big in the business world. Both plots are similarly wrapped around these relationships.
In contrast, there are plenty of differences between both authors writing styles. Miller uses a very unorthodox style in how he goes along with the plot. Most authors don’t choose to do so, but he went along and attempted to blur the main characters present and past. This style is in direct relation with the overbearing theme of the play. Meanwhile Shakespeare uses one of his most original styles in Hamlet. There is a combination of verse poetry, in which most commonly he uses iambic pentameter. As well as prose, which is just like Miller’s style in Death of a Salesman. Prose being the writing style or method of dialogue that is used everyday. Or how people talk on a daily basis and is not in any type of verse or rhyme. “How noble in reason! how infinite in faculty! in form, in moving, how express and admirable! in action how like an angel! in apprehension how like a god! the beauty of the world! the paragon of animals! And yet, to me, what is this quintessence of dust?” (Act 2, Scene 2) This being one of the more famous examples of prose. Another difference between the authors is how they pace each. Miller being more of a modern author and using prose, has a much quicker pace in the literary piece than Shakespeare’s Hamlet. The tone of Hamlet written by Shakespeare is more of a dark and uncertain one. Hamlet is a very dark play and it starts off from the very beginning and leaves the audience and readers thinking. “Who’s there?” (Act 1, Scene 1). Puts the reader into a state of mind where thoughts of anxiety and uncertainty come into play. Whereas in Death of a Salesman, the diction and tone is quite intense. Readers may not even realize this however. Through the use of this, Miller is able to give off easily what the protagonist of the play Willy must go through and the hardships of his life. There are plenty of pressures modern society places on WIlly in the play. Which also makes the tone tragic.
Lastly in conclusion, Arthur Miller and William Shakespeare share plenty of similarities in both of these wonderfully done literary pieces. Including a shared focus on the plot and concepts. Which makes it quite easy to compare their styles of writing. Yet easily the two authors in Hamlet and Death of a Salesman showed plenty of their differences as well. The largest difference being the style of their writing and how they portrayed characters with this style. The ways Miller and Shakespeare wrote these shows a clear sophistication in their literature. This being the reason why these two plays have remained popular and relevant years after their creation.  
 

Hawthorne and Walker- Fisher

Nathaniel Hawthorne and Alice Walker have produced two classic pieces of American Literature in The Scarlet Letter and The Color Purple, respectively. Both novels are critically acclaimed, and continue to be read on a massive scale even today. These two authors are very similar in the themes they focus on, as well as the messages they attempt to convey through their work. However, differences in perspective, tone,  and writing style separate Hawthorne from Walker. Comparing The Scarlet Letter and The Color Purple provides a clear example of all these factors in action.
First these authors both chose to focus on the central theme of the role of women in society. The main idea that women faced severe discrimination and were at an unfair disadvantage in society was effectively used by both authors.  In addition, sexual conduct is a topic which both authors explore in a fair amount of detail. This is exemplified in the excessive humiliation society puts on Hester Prynne for her adultery, as well as the constant physical and sexual abuse Celie faces throughout the novel. Perhaps the best description of the abuse Celie faces comes on the very first page, where she describes the actions of the worst abuser in her life, her father, as “He never had a kine word to say to me. Just say You gonna do what your mammy wouldn’t” (Walker, 1). Their choices in theme say a lot about these two authors, and part of what makes them so great is their willingness to tackle controversial, impactful topics such as the role of women and their sexuality in society.
Through the establishment of those themes, both authors conveyed a powerful message about strength. In Hawthorne’s novel, Hester accepts her situation and stays strong despite the extremely difficult circumstances she finds herself in. For example, when Madame Hester is first paraded out before the public, she refuses to be controlled by her captors, as the book describes in saying “On the threshold of the prison door, she repelled him,by an action marked with natural dignity and force of character, and stepped into the open air, as if by her own free will” (Hawthorne 61). This quote details the strength Hester displayed in keeping her dignity. Similarly, through her talks with Sofia, Celie learned to be strong and not accept abuse, which eventually led to her developing a healthy relationship with Mr.___. This is seen during  conversation between the two early in the novel, where Sofia says “I loves Harpo, God knows I do, but I’ll kill him dead before I let him beat me” (Walker, 40). This statement opens Celie’s eyes to the possibility of being strong in the face of abuse. The fact that both of these authors chose to portray a positive message speaks to their priorities in writing, and the juxtaposition represented by the message of strength and all the negative events of the two novels is what makes these two authors so brilliant. The presence of a positive message for the reader to take from these negative stories (especially in Hawthorne’s case) is partly what defines these two authors’ best pieces.
The defining difference between the works of  Hawthorne and Walker in this case is the perspective from which the authors chose to tell the story. The Color Purple is very unique, because the entire story is told through Celie’s first person perspective, and all the information is given in the form of letters written after the events of the day, rather than being told in the moment. Walker’s decision to write from this perspective has it’s pros and cons. On the one hand, the reader is able to get an in depth look into the main character’s thoughts and feelings, because she the entire novel is told from her view, and the letter writing aspect gives her an opportunity to reflect in depth on the events going on around her. In addition, the mystery of not knowing how other characters truly feel makes the book more enjoyable for readers. However, character development does suffer through Walker’s choice in perspective, because all other characters besides Celie are not fleshed out in detail by not being able to comment on the story. In contrast, Hawthorne chooses the third person omniscient perspective, which is the exact opposite of the first person as used by Walker. The third person omniscient approach is beneficial because it allows the reader to always know what is going on with all characters all the time, which creates a better overall reading experience than only knowing the thoughts of one character. However, a downside to Hawthorne’s choice in perspective is that it does not allow the reader to develop a close personal connection with any one particular character.        
  Finally, a major difference between the two authors lies in their writing style. Hawthorne’s novel is written with sophisticated and powerful diction, as many people would imagine a brilliant writer to write. Hawthorne uses lengthy and detailed sentences to flesh out his story, always using advanced vocabulary and diction. On the other hand, Walker’s writing style is a stark contrast. While it is obviously a product of the perspective the story is told through and the point she is trying to make, Walker writes in broken English and uses very basic diction and syntax. While there is not a good or bad writing style, the choices made by the two authors in this regard are what most set these famous books apart.
In conclusion, Nathaniel Hawthorne and Alice Walker shared a similar theme of difficulties facing women, and conveyed a very similar message of strength through their novels The Scarlet Letter and The Color Purple, respectively. However, the two authors were very different in both the perspectives they chose to tell their story from, as well as the writing style used. While there is much debate as to the merits of the way the authors write, it is clear that they have both crafted classic American novels.     

    

Morrison and Hawthorne - Fenneuff

When it comes to the style of two books, none are as different as are Toni Morrison’s Sula and Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter. The books are both regarded as stellar pieces of literature, however, the two could not be any more different.
Of course, the two books were written in vastly different time frames. The Scarlet Letter was first published in 1850, while Sula was first published in 1973. Because of this over a century long gap, the writing styles are quite different. Hawthorne uses more intricate, complicated wording, as was the style of the time, while Morrison, adjusting to the more modern literature style of the time, uses simpler, less complex language. Hawthorne's story uses Olde English, which can at times be a struggle to get through, while Morrison provides readers with a less complicated, more modern writing style which is much easier to read and interpret. 
Each author's way of telling the story is different as well. Morrison creates two characters that start off with separate story lines that become entwined as the story goes on. Hawthorne only has one story line with a handful of characters that progresses naturally and is a strong enough story line that it does not need to rely on another one to make the story feel complete and logical. The Scarlet Letter starts off with a lengthy introduction, then dives into the story, which is put together seamlessly, broken up only by chapters that flow together and connect easily. Sula breaks the story up more concretely, first into two separate parts, and then furthermore separates the story by breaking the two parts up into chapters. Each chapter takes place during a different year, which is made clear at the beginning of each chapter, where the year the chapter takes place during is printed boldly at the top. Morrison’s way of dividing the story into years, rather than having it progress naturally as Hawthorne does, results in the story making occasional jumps as far as time is concerned, but provides a clear time line so that the reader does not get lost. With The Scarlet Letter there is no need for a dated timeline because the story is straightforward and does not contain any lapses in time.
The style that books are formatted in contributes greatly to the way that the reader interprets and intakes the story, and Morrison and Hawthorne chose very different ways to format their books. Morrison chose to start each chapter, or year, on a new page which shows clear distinction between each part of the story. Hawthorne chooses to do quite the opposite. The chapters in The Scarlet Letter are separated only by a heading, and rather than starting each chapter on a new page, one chapter ends on the same page that another chapter begins. The chapters are not separated as distinctly in The Scarlet Letter as they are in Sula, because the separate parts of The Scarlet Letter do not need to be as clearly defined as they do in Sula due to the way that time progresses and the way that the story is organised in each book.
Hawthorne uses more powerful and distinguished descriptors throughout his story. For example: “’…not to an earthly physician!’ cried Mr. Dimmesdale, passionately, and turning his eyes, full and bright, and with a kind of fierceness, on old Rodger Chillingworth” (94). His descriptions are more literal and specific, and provide the reader with the vision or interpretation that Hawthorne wants the reader to have. Hawthorne allows for limited, but not completely restricted, use of the reader’s imagination. It’s similar to bowling with bumpers: one may throw the ball however they wish, but regardless, the ball will ultimately end up rolling down the bowling lane, ending up where it was intended to go. Morrison, on the other hand, relies on the imagination of the reader to create the story. Morrison uses more metaphorical descriptions throughout her story such as: “he was full of such dreams… his hands already curved to the pick handle” (82) and “Her parents had succeeded in rubbing down to a dull glow any sparkle or splutter she had” (83).  Morrison triggers the reader’s imagination and requires the reader to interpret her words in their own way, allowing the reader to complete the story in a more literal sense where she chose use metaphorical descriptors instead. Readers are free to fill in the blanks that were left by Morrison by not providing a descriptive, literal definition of the goings-on of the characters.

Overall, Sula is an easier, slightly more enjoyable read. While the times of both books are outdated, the story of Sula is much more modern than The Scarlet Letter. The events in Sula are slightly easier to relate to, or at least comprehend. It is harder for modern-day readers to even fathom or understand the events in The Scarlet Letter, simply due to the fact that the time frame and dramatics of the story are not very relatable to what most readers have had to deal with current day. In addition, the less complicated writing style and word choice of Sula is not as hard to understand as The Scarlet Letter. That’s not to say that Sula is an easy read, or that The Scarlet Letter is impossible to get through: they both have similar levels of challenge, however, the writing style of Sula keeps with the times and is easier to understand while the writing style of The Scarlet Letter is simply outdated and more difficult to understand. 

Friday, July 22, 2016

Steinbeck and Walker by Carlson

Great authors have the ability to take you into a different world simply by only sharing to you what’s inside their head. To each of us the world is a completely different place, and it feels different to all of us based on our own experiences. The Grapes of Wrath, and The Color Purple are both written in the same time period, around the late 1930’s early 1940’s. The Grapes of Wrath focused on the depression, while The Color Purple focused on racism and brutality towards blacks, and the issues they face with each other. As these are so varied, it shows you how different both of these authors wrote.

John Steinbeck writing was pessimistic, he often wrote in a direct and cut-throat sort of way, such as “... the dog, a blot of blood and tangled, burst intestines, kicked slowly in the road.” (pg 44) He writes with very little emotion, he does this in a way to really allow you to get into the times and how the characters thought. During the Depression, many people were numb, and felt very defeated. Steinbeck’s writing style complements this by showing a lack of emotion and description. Steinbeck also has an enjoyable view point that he switches quite often. He would switch from the Joad family viewpoint, (still in third person, however) to the immigrants and poverty-stricken people. He does this to allow you to see how it’s like on the inside, and up close and personal, while you are following the Joads, and then to see how it is looking on the outside, as if you were God or some other being watching the world. This gives you the knowledge of just how bad the Great Depression was, and its impact on not only the Joads, but on all families.


Although The Color Purple is written in a letter form, in the direct viewpoint of Celie, an actual character in the story, Celie is so numb from the abuse of her childhood and adulthood that Alice Walker also writes in a sort of numb way, which many associate with being a pessimistic viewpoint as well. Walker does something successfully however that many cannot do, and that is being able to write without using quotation marks. Celie does not use quotation marks either because she is uneducated, or because she is writing letters to Nettie and she feels it unnecessary, or a little of both,  Walker is granted the ability to write without quotations, and she does this very successfully, as the reader still has the ability to understand what each character is saying, what is unravelling in the plot, and feels as if it is more so a conversation or letter, and that they are Nettie receiving it. Walker seemed to try to make this sort of impact by switching back to the Joad family, but didn’t quite get the closeness to the Joads for the reader as the reader felt towards Celie or Nettie, because of the letter form of the story.


Both Steinbeck and Walker did a phenomenal job of making you believe the characters were real, and had actually existed during their time. Both authors added accents to the characters that would’ve likely had at the time, such as Steinbeck here, “ He ain't gonna look natural. We'll wrop him up." (pg 95) Ain’t and wrop are both modified to make the reader know how it would sound to hear those characters in person. Walker did it here, “I tell her she can’t be all the time going to visit her sister. Us married now, I tell her. Your place is here with the children.
She say, I’ll take the children with me.” (pg 29) By both authors doing this it allowed you to connect with the characters, and allowed them to seem more tangible and real.

Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Atwood and McCarthy, Seeger

On the surface, The Handmaid’s Tale, written by Margaret Atwood, and The Road, written by Cormac McCarthy, share many commonalities. Both stories take place in a chaotic setting following the collapse of modern society. They both utilize the reader's prior knowledge of modern America in order to create a vastly different society that rejects the current norms and morals of today. And yet, the writing styles of the two novels are very different. There are markable distinctions in the two authors’ approaches to how their characters exist in the worlds that they have created. The individual writing styles of Atwood and McCarthy offer two different experiences for readers, as evident by their differing uses of structure, point of view, and syntax, among other literary devices.
The novel The Handmaid’s Tale is organized according to division of thoughts. Similar ideas are linked together, and new ideas are introduced in a new chapter. There is an overall sense of order to the book, and it is relatively easy to follow the plot of the story. In contrast, The Road is often just a collection of jumbled thoughts. There is no real division of ideas or expression, and there are no chapters; the plot flows from one point to another with little notice of a shift in the story line. The lack of formal punctuation contributes to the unorganized feel of the book; there are rarely any commas or apostrophes, and dialogue is almost never in quotation marks. McCarthy likely utilized this technique in order to illustrate the extreme informality and crudeness of the setting that he has created. One similarity between the two novels in terms of structure is their frequent use of flashbacks. Both authors utilize memories of their protagonists in order to introduce painful aspects of their past.. These remembrances offer the reader insight into the backstory of the characters, as well as establish a point of origin for their approaches towards the lives that they are forced to live in their new environment.
Both of the novels differ on the point of view that they are told in. The Handmaid’s Tale is told in the first person, while The Road is told in the third person. These differing viewpoints create two different degrees of emotional and personal involvement with regards to the protagonists in each respective novel. The story of Offred, the protagonist in The Handmaid’s Tale, is able to be told on a more personal and sincere level because of the first person narrative used in the novel. The emotional aspect of the novel is heightened due to the fact that she herself is sharing her beliefs and feelings rather than an uninvolved third party. In contrast, the story of the Man from The Road is told in the third person: because The Road is told from this point of view, the characters are more detached from their emotions. This is likely a technique that the author purposely employed. McCarthy created an inhospitable and miserable environment that left the characters in his novel unable to fully accept their situation, allowing for the readers to project their own personal emotional response on the situations that the characters encounter.
Atwood creates a reading experience that is so full of intense description that at times it reads more as poetry than as a novel. Phrases such as “a willow, weeping catkins; around the edges, the flower borders, in which the daffodils are now fading and the tulips are opening their cups, spilling out color”(Atwood 12) are used consistently throughout the book to describe otherwise ordinary settings and situations. This writing style allows for the readers to become immersed in her world, and to visualize Offred’s daily experiences on a realistic and believable level. McCarthy also writes, at times, in poetic phrasing. He uses expressions such as “...the amber current where the white edges of their fins wimpled softly in the flow”(McCarthy 286) to add further interest to his story. McCarthy is less vibrant vivid in his descriptions; in contrast to Atwood, McCarthy is more blunt in his worldbuilding, and relies less on vibrant and colorful descriptions to move the story forward.
Both The Road and The Handmaid’s Tale place emphasis on similar themes. One of the main themes of both novels is the importance of children. Atwood and McCarthy both create worlds in which children are revered, either the Man’s devotion towards the Boy or the societal value that Gilead places on fertility and reproduction. Additionally, the question of identity is central to both novels. Throughout The Handmaid’s Tale, Offred struggles with reconciling her past identity, defined by the life that she had created with her husband and child, with the identity that Gileadean society attempts to place on her, where she is expected to be subservient, submissive, and fertile. McCarthy also deals with the theme of identity in The Road. Throughout the novel, the Man and the Boy continually try to convince themselves that they are good, that they are carrying the flame and would never resort to the savage acts that they see being committed on a daily basis by others around them.  
Despite the fact that The Road and The Handmaid’s Tale share some consistencies between them, both novelists utilize different writing styles in order to develop their characters and drive their stories forward. Both novels are exceptionally unique in the way that the story itself is written and in the manner that the characters respond to the challenging situations presented to them.